08
Dec
Posted by Yehuda Berlinger as Modern Board Games
Normally I would save this for a pimping roundup, but it’s priceless.
The staff writers for the Fort Worth Star Telegram reviewed seven “new” games, and here’s what they came up with:
- Loopit: Grade A. “Loopit is like Scrabble, only for people who don’t want to fight with their relatives over a word choice.”
- Clue: the Office: Grade A. “The weapons are all inside jokes for those who watch the show and kept us laughing.”
- WordQuest: Grade B. “Attractive, easy to learn and play.”
- Pandemic: Grade C. “Pandemic is too complicated. Just setting up the board took half an hour the first time, thanks to multiple sets of cards, cubes, tokens and pawns.”
- Pop the Pig: Grade D. “A few minutes of entertainment for smaller children.”
- Incan Gold: Grade F. “Our 16-year-old was writhing on the floor with frustration because after 25 minutes, we still couldn’t figure out how to start the game and play the first round.”
- Ticket to Ride: Grade F. “Unnecessarily complicated. There are no dice or “action” modes.”
Thanks for the insight, staff writers!
(source)
[…] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Dave Gilligan, Purple Pawn. Purple Pawn said: Forth Worth Star Telegram Writers Diss Better Games: Normally I would save this for a pimping roundup, but it’s p… http://bit.ly/6fJRz2 […]
And yet, those of us who actually play games other than on a holiday news assignment blithely think that the day when Euro-style gaming goes mainstream is just around the corner…
This is painful to read. Even in summary!
This is exactly why the concept of “mainstream gaming” is an oxymoron.
[…] This post was Twitted by seanabrady […]
Are you serious? Pandemic and Ticket to Ride too complicated? Sad…
Days of Wonder even has videos on their site to teach you how to play. This is why people don’t read newspapers any more.
Forget Pandemic and Ticket to Ride, these brain surgeons couldn’t figure out Incan Gold. Yes, Incan Gold, a game I routinely play with my 4 and 7 year old kids.
Apparently my 4-year old is more qualified to review games for the Star-Telegram than the numbskulls they’re currently paying to do it.
Yes, it was probably a half-assed article.
But frankly they’re probably saving their talent for more important topics. This was filler.
Remember, though, that most gamers are used to reading rules.
But most folks aren’t that way.
If a journalist doesn’t understand the game, chances are the average person won’t, either. In this article the reporters are telling your average Life and Monopoly family, “These games are probably too complicated to give you the fun you’re used to.”
Seriously, Loopit is the best game on this list. All you complainers… have you played all of these games? Loop it is a lot of fun and Ticket to Ride isn’t that fun.